Contact Us


  • Our cakes are all made by hand right here on our store. All cakes are 9″ round and can be customized for your occasion. When ordering your cake, we have 2 options to choose from:

    OPTION 1 ($27.95): The Old Fashioned –One layer of Vanilla Ice Cream & One Layer of Chocolate Ice Cream, with Chocolate Crunchies and Fudge in the middle. OPTION 2 ($29.00 + $3.00 for each custom flavor): Create-A-Cake – Customize your cake by choosing up to two different scoop flavors from our counter and adding in your favorite toppings for the middle (please note that our flavors may change during the year, and many not be available at all times)
  • Please use this online form to order a custom cake. Note that we require a minimum of 72 hours (3 Days) notice. We also have pre-made cakes in the store that are available if you need one in less time. We will call to confirm your order.

    First, we just need a little information about you:
  • When do you need the cake? (Note the we require 72 hours / 3 Days notice for all custom ice cream cakes.
  • Now, tell us about the kind of cake you would like.

    Let's start with the bottom:
  • We will call you to confirm before we create it.

Click the button below to download our form.

Learn More

  • MM slash DD slash YYYY

Mendham Creamery Hours

Monday – Friday: 3:00 p.m. – 9:00 p.m.
Saturday & Sunday: Noon – 9:00 p.m